Dev diary
June 23–24, 2026
A whole harness in two days
My first commit, Initial commit: defeasible reasoning harness
, came with four design documents I’d written beforehand: an epistemic constitution (the norms), context-management principles (critics stay independent), an orchestration spec, and a build brief. The core idea was there from the start. LLM “leaves” each do one job on a status-blinded slice of an argument graph, and a deterministic Dung grounded-semantics engine computes which claims stand.
The first two days had 47 commits. The operations went in one at a time: steelmanning, counterexamples, reframing, source appraisal and evidence-seeking, distinction-drawing, surfacing hidden assumptions, and finally an explicit stopping rule. By that evening the log reads O10 termination judgment — the explicit stopping rule (all 12 ops complete).
A graded layer (DF-QuAD) went alongside the binary verdicts. Then came a self-contained HTML viewer that replays a run move by move, and a plain-language narrator.
One early commit set the tone for the whole project: docs: correct O2 run observation — the reframe was operationally inert.
I fixed it in the next commit.
Dev diary
Late June – early July
Making it usable
Multi-provider models with per-operation model and effort choices, parallel LLM calls, a chat-to-graph intake (the “front door”) and a local web app. On July 1 a structured review of the reasoning structure was implemented in six stages. Among the changes: per-claim case review, and counterexamples grounded in evidence instead of free invention.
Dev diary
July 6–14
The conversational harness
A sibling built from philosophy of language rather than epistemology. The Conversational Constitution (norms K1–K8, operations T1–T14) grew to about 124 KB. The build ran in steps: a score spine updated only by typed moves, an interpretation ladder, felicity validation with a “reject, don’t guess” rule, then four model leaves on top. Two adversarial reviews in the first day each found real defects. July 7–13 was a full calibration phase, with sweeps, a human-tier adjudication, and a ruling that one judge “was the defect.” Then came the “conversation x-ray”, an observer-only web front end.
Dev diary
July 13–27
Fusion, and learning from live sessions
The reasoning and conversational harnesses were joined so that a conversation’s claims become a “doxastic web” that the deliberation engine settles. The case-law ledger ran to 54 entries over two weeks. Each entry reviewed a live session, named the defects, ruled fixes and smoke-tested them, usually all on the same day. The subjects trace the system growing up: verdict always ships
, the narrator is starved behind the high-stakes refusal storm
, best session yet; turn 5 walled on one false contrary
, first wall-free session
. A documentation site went up on July 25–27.